Best Car Insurance In Michigan

Best Car Insurance In Michigan : Looking for best and inexpensive car insurance in Michigan? Our staff studied Michigan’s no-fault insurance regulations, needed coverage, and lowest vehicle insurance providers.

Car Insurance In Michigan

Find out which Michigan auto insurer we recommend.

Michigan Auto Insurance

Michigan’s auto insurance rules are complex. Because of Michigan’s no-fault regulations, drivers can’t pursue accident claims against other drivers’ insurance companies. Michigan’s numerous laws and mandated coverages make vehicle insurance more expensive than normal.

You might discover affordable Michigan car insurance if you shop around and investigate top suppliers.

Michigan’s cheapest auto insurance?

Progressive offers the lowest vehicle insurance in Michigan, with an average monthly premium of $140 and an annual rate of $1,682. USAA, Auto-Owners, and AAA are also reasonable.

Cheapest Michigan car insurance providers’ monthly and annual costs

  • Progressive $140 $1,682
  • USAA $148 $1,780
  • Auto-Owners $185 $2,221
  • AAA $225 $2,696

Michigan auto insurance cost?

Michigan full coverage vehicle insurance is $369 per month or $4,430 per year. This is twice the national average of $1,732.  (Rates for a 35-year-old driver with a clean record and decent credit.)

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners ranks Michigan second for car insurance costs (NAIC).

In Michigan, auto insurance companies can’t base premiums on sex, marital status, homeownership, credit score, education, occupation, or zip code.

Young drivers, Michigan’s cheapest car insurance

Young drivers pay more for auto insurance in Michigan, according to our estimates. Here are the cheapest full-coverage companies for young drivers.

Car Insurance Monthly/Annual Rate Estimate

  • Progressive $184 $2,204
  • USAA $186 $2,234
  • Auto-Owners $247 $2,964
  • AAA $305 $3,655

Cheapest Michigan Auto Insurance: Speeding

Speeding fines raise insurance costs. Progressive offers the cheapest rate for drivers with a speeding ticket, $171 per month or $2,047 per year for full coverage. Here are other economical auto insurers.

Car Insurance Monthly/Annual Rate Estimate

  • Progressive $171 $2,047
  • USAA $206 $2,471
  • Auto-Owners $279 $3,347
  • AAA $349 $4,188
  • Frankenmuth $419 $5,033

Accidents, Cheapest Michigan Car Insurance

At-fault accidents can raise your rate. If you’ve had an accident, these companies offer affordable car insurance in Michigan.

Car Insurance Monthly/Annual Rate Estimate

  • Progressive $184 $2,210
  • USAA $211 $2,530
  • Auto-Owners $212 $2,538
  • AAA $314 $3,767

Best Michigan Car Insurance

Since Michiganders pay more for coverage, everyone wants the greatest policy at the lowest price. We investigated the finest auto insurance providers in Michigan based on customer satisfaction, ease of claims, and quality of coverage.

Average cost of Michigan Motor1 car insurance

  • 1. Autoinsurance 4.4 $2,221
  • 2. USAA Automobilversicherung 4.8 $2,696
  • 3. Geico Automobilversicherung 4.6 N/A
  • 4. 4.6 $1,682

*We didn’t include all providers in our state cost estimates. Some vehicle insurance firms with lower star ratings are listed higher. Our evaluations consider nationwide considerations, whereas our ranking focuses on Michigan car insurance providers.

#1 Auto-Owners

Auto-Owners Insurance has an A+ BBB rating and an A++ AM Best rating. It’s a Forbes 500 firm and has won national accolades for customer service, quality, and employee treatment. Insurance has covered drivers since 1916 and now has three million customers. Auto-Owners has 47,000 licenced agents in 26 states and is headquartered in Michigan. The company’s app lets you check a claim’s status, examine your insurance card, and pay your premium.

Auto-Owners gives the basics plus the following:-

  • Roadside service 24/7
  • Rent-a-car refund
  • Closures
  • Auto-owners pros, cons

To receive a quotation, contact a local insurance agent in Michigan.

  • Applicable
  • Coverage gaps
  • Auto+Pkg


USAA automobile insurance is perfect for current or past service members. In our study, we found fair prices and good customer service. J.D. Power and Associates, Inc. Power rates USAA highly. USAA scored the highest in the J.D. 2021 U.S. Insurance StudySM.

USAA offers conventional coverages and extras including new car replacement, accident forgiveness, rental car reimbursement, towing, and glass coverage. USAA offers discounts for safe drivers, individuals who attend driver training classes, and deployed military members who keep their vehicles.

USAA’s customer service impresses. This is crucial given many providers’ low claims handling scores.

USAA pros/cons

  • Military and their families receive discounts and affordable rates.
  • Good for young and military drivers
  • BBB gives A+ for financial strength.

Our USAA insurance review has more information.


Geico scored 4.6 out of 5.0 ratings for its great reputation, moderate costs, and comprehensive coverage.

Also Geico boasts A+ BBB and A++ AM Best ratings from auto insurance specialists. These ratings show Geico’s trustworthy customer service and ability to pay claims.

All Geico policies have these benefits:

  • Optional coverage
  • Affordable nationwide coverage
  • All options include roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement.
  • Geico also offers mechanical breakdown insurance to protect your finances from costly repairs.

Geico pros/cons

BBB’s A+ rating and superior financial strength

Car Insurance In Michigan


Our reviewers rated Progressive 4.6 out of 5. The insurer’s A+ AM Best rating indicates its ability to pay claims reliably.

Progressive offers two methods to help you save on vehicle insurance:

  • Progressive Snapshot® Program: A usage-based safe driving app that monitors safe driving to award discounts.
  • Name Your Price® Tool: Compare Progressive’s prices to other top insurance providers’ rates to find the best price.

Progressive pros/cons

  • Top US auto insurer Average claims process
  • Strong financials, mixed customer service
  • High-risk drivers should get this.
  • Easy quote procedure and money-saving features

Michigan Car Insurance

Progressive vehicle insurance review.

Auto Insurance Basics

  • Each state regulates vehicle insurance minimums. Every state requires a combination of these five coverage types.
  • This covers another person’s injuries if you cause an automobile accident.
  • Property damage liability (PD) helps cover costs if you cause an auto accident.
  • If the at-fault driver is uninsured, your injuries and those of your passengers are covered.
  • This coverage pays for car damage if the at-fault driver is uninsured.
  • Personal injury protection (PIP) covers medical fees and other injury-related expenditures in several states (i.e. lost income).

Michigan No-Fault Policy

Michigan is one of 12 states with “no-fault” auto insurance. In a no-fault state, vehicle insurance covers medical fees and other out-of-pocket damages regardless of who caused the accident. Michigan’s no-fault insurance statute is convoluted and has inconsistencies.

You and your insurance carrier are responsible for any losses and expenses in the event of an accident, regardless of responsibility. Instead, your deductible and pre-insurance fees will differ based on fault.

Due to these laws, your personal insurance will cover most or all accident damages and injuries. This implies you’ll rarely (if ever) make claims against another person’s insurance and likely won’t be covered for “pain and suffering” or other damages.

Michigan’s no-fault law requires all drivers to have PIP. The state used to mandate unlimited PIP coverage, but the legislation changed in 2020 and now allows drivers $50,000, $250,000, and $500,000 policy limits. Drivers can still get unlimited PIP insurance. Michigan no-fault insurance also covers property (PPI).

Michigan insurance requirements

Before choosing the finest auto insurance in Michigan, you must know what’s required. Michigan state minimums:

Type/amount of insurance

  • $50,000 per person, $100,000 per accident
  • $10,000 accident property damage
  • Personal injury protection up to $50,000, $250,000, $500,000, or limitless
  • $1,000,000 property insurance
  • Optional uninsured/underinsured motorist
  • Optional collision, extensive
  • MCCA Charge

Michigan drivers must pay a Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association charge. Only fully insured vehicles in storage are exempt from the MCCA cost.

Michigan’s uninsured motorist fines

Michigan doesn’t automatically track uninsured drivers, but all car owners must produce proof of insurance when renewing registration and plates. Michigan drivers must always carry insurance proof.

If a Michigan police officer requests proof of insurance, you could face the following penalties:

  • Revocation
  • Registration and plates not renewed
  • $50 legal fine

Car Insurance Shopping Tips

1. Beyond state minimal coverage, examine what policy meets your needs. If you’re driving a new automobile with a loan, you’ll need comprehensive and collision coverage.

No auto insurance covers manufacturer-defect fixes. Extended car warranties offer these extra coverages.

2. Your driving record affects your insurance prices. Michigan’s points system only records violations for two years.

3. Clean driving records, driver safety classes, and more can earn savings from car insurance carriers. If you own a home or need other insurance, choose firms who offer all of these so you can get a multi-policy discount.

4. Although you may want to remain loyal to a person or organisation that has treated you well, it’s a good idea to compare numerous vehicle insurance rates and shop around for auto insurance every few years. Our staff studied Michigan’s no-fault insurance regulations, needed coverage, and lowest vehicle insurance providers. Find out which Michigan auto insurer we recommend.

Best Car Insurance In Michigan

  • Michigan Auto Insurance
  • Michigan’s cheapest auto insurance?
  • Best Michigan Car Insurance
  • Auto Insurance Basics
  • Michigan insurance requirements
  • Car Insurance Shopping Tips
  • Michigan Insurance FAQ
  • Methodology
  • Michigan Auto Insurance


Leave a Comment